Is Your Return Policy Hurting Your Business?
By: Ritchie Sayner
Let’s be honest, who really likes returns? As retailers, you are in the business of selling merchandise, not taking it back, right? After all, returns take time and generally mean the customer had a negative experience with the merchandise or simply had a change of heart, and now their problem is soon going to become your problem.
Full disclosure here, that used to be my mindset. I dreaded seeing our bags coming back into the store. My hunch is that a lot of you may feel the same way.
During the years, returns of retail sales have steadily increased, with 9 percent of retail sales being returned, according to the Kurt Salmon consulting firm. The latest figures available suggest that returns in 2014 hit $284 billion, up 6.2 percent from the previous year. Some attribute this increase to online shopping since one-third of online purchases come back.
I decided to poll a crosssection of retailers that I consult with to find out what their return policies are. I wasn’t terribly surprised with what I learned. It appears that the smaller the volume a store does, the stricter their return policy is. The general consensus being that smaller retailers feel they simply can’t afford a more liberal policy, thus opting for store credits in lieu of cash refunds and a tighter window in which returns are accepted. Larger volume operations, on the other hand, approach this issue with a completely different philosophy, or so it would seem. Larger stores, in general, adopt the approach that “If the customer isn’t happy, they probably aren’t coming back.” They also seem to allow the customer a longer period of time in which to make a decision on the merchandise. Thirty days appears to be the norm.
Other discoveries from my unscientific poll were that final sale items were not returnable. That seems reas nable to me, unless the product is defective, in which case it should become a vendor issue. Most retailers responded that any returns had to have the sales receipt and could not show any signs of wear. Again, larger volume retailers are a bit more lenient here. One store, in particular, actually advertises that customers can exchange footwear they have worn if the pair isn’t working for them within 30 days. A liberal policy such as that takes away any fear a customer may have regarding the purchase.
Might a case be made that larger volume stores became that way over time because, among other things, they were willing to do what the custom r wanted them to do? Next time you are confronted with a return that seems questionable, try asking the customer what they would like you to do to make them happy. If a store credit is going to annoy a customer to the point of creating hard feelings, is it really worth it? To the stores that feel they must keep the money “in the store,” it might be time to rethink this approach. I contend you keep more money in the store in the long run by making the customer happy. That may mean giving more cash refunds.
Looking at returns from another perspective, we might see that the customer has made yet another visit to our store. How can we make this a positive experience for everyone? The customer had to spend their time and money to come back into the store to return something that they feel justified about. I will offer an idea that is sure to garner an eye roll from some.
Consider offering a customer a $5 credit “for their trouble” once you have completed the return/exchange to their satisfactio ? That might get some very positive kudos on Yelp. Believe me, that $5 will come back to you in multiples. You have to give to get.
All Sales Are Final! Wow, that makes me want to buy … not!
How about something more customer-centric, such as “All Sales Are Final When You Are Completely Satisfied”? My belief is that smaller stores would grow their volume by actually promoting a more liberal return policy emphasizing complete customer satisfaction. Many smaller stores see themselves at the mercy of the Internet due to its sheer magnitude, as well as the whims of larger retailers. Believe me; tightening up the return policy does nothing to combat this.
I know of one merchant who took back a pair of shoes he never carried because the customer was adamant that the shoes were purchased at his store. His mindset being, “I can refuse this unjustified return and guarantee I will never see this person in my store again – and risk additional negative social media backlash – or I can graciously accept the return, ask the customer what she would like us to do and hopefully turn a negative into a positive.” You might say he chose to lose the battle, yet win the war.
There are times when a retailer should mark down a customer. If you have a customer who habitually takes advantage of your return policy or is abusive to your employees, it may be time for them to take their business to a c mpetitor. Obviously, your store is not a good match for this customer and in some cases it is best to part company.
Revisit your return policy; talk with your store managers, sales associates and even a few of your better customers. Ask them if your return policy is hurting your business? Remember, however; never make a rule that negatively affects the many based on the actions of a few.
[Ritchie Sayner is vice president of business development RMSA Retail Solutions, www.rmsa.com. To follow him on Facebook, go to www.facebook. com/RitchieSayner.]
About Inside Outdoor Magazine:
We know outdoor executives have access to plenty of instantaneous information. But one thing decision makers overwhelmingly tell us they can’t get enough of is thoroughly researched and highly scrutinized news and analysis that can be applied directly to improving day-to-day operations.
Having surpassed more than a decade in the industry, Inside Outdoor Magazine’s staff of seasoned outdoor journalists represent years of experience in specialty retail, product manufacturing, business analysis and living the outdoor lifestyle. We believe this mix of backgrounds is a key component to complementing your marketing message with the business modeling, cost-margin analysis, trend forecasting and quantified operational advice that’s already proven to capture loyalty and engage readers, and studies show that reader engagement with media and advertising can drive sales.
Your customers would need to expend significant time and money to amass the information and advice, in addition to, the requisite industry movements, trends and product innovations—that we deliver straight to their mailboxes, for free, all year round.